WORST_CASE(?,O(n^2)) * Step 1: DependencyPairs WORST_CASE(?,O(n^2)) + Considered Problem: - Strict TRS: bsort(0(),xs) -> xs bsort(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubblesort(xs) -> bsort(len(xs),xs) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) - Signature: {+/2, c_1() bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)) len#(Nil()) -> c_7() Weak DPs +#(x,S(0())) -> c_8() +#(S(0()),y) -> c_9() <#(x,0()) -> c_10() <#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11() <#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) and mark the set of starting terms. * Step 2: PredecessorEstimation WORST_CASE(?,O(n^2)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bsort#(0(),xs) -> c_1() bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)) len#(Nil()) -> c_7() - Weak DPs: +#(x,S(0())) -> c_8() +#(S(0()),y) -> c_9() <#(x,0()) -> c_10() <#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11() <#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bsort(0(),xs) -> xs bsort(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubblesort(xs) -> bsort(len(xs),xs) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, c_1() 2: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) 3: bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() 4: bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)) 5: bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) 6: len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)) 7: len#(Nil()) -> c_7() 8: +#(x,S(0())) -> c_8() 9: +#(S(0()),y) -> c_9() 10: <#(x,0()) -> c_10() 11: <#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11() 12: <#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)) 13: bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) 14: bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) * Step 3: RemoveWeakSuffixes WORST_CASE(?,O(n^2)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)) - Weak DPs: +#(x,S(0())) -> c_8() +#(S(0()),y) -> c_9() <#(x,0()) -> c_10() <#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11() <#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)) bsort#(0(),xs) -> c_1() bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) len#(Nil()) -> c_7() - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bsort(0(),xs) -> xs bsort(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubblesort(xs) -> bsort(len(xs),xs) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) -->_2 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)):3 -->_1 bsort#(0(),xs) -> c_1():11 -->_2 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():2 -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)):1 2:S:bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() 3:S:bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)) -->_1 bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)):13 -->_1 bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)):12 -->_2 <#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)):10 -->_2 <#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11():9 -->_2 <#(x,0()) -> c_10():8 4:S:bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) -->_2 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)):5 -->_2 len#(Nil()) -> c_7():14 -->_1 bsort#(0(),xs) -> c_1():11 -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)):1 5:S:len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)) -->_2 len#(Nil()) -> c_7():14 -->_1 +#(S(0()),y) -> c_9():7 -->_1 +#(x,S(0())) -> c_8():6 -->_2 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)):5 6:W:+#(x,S(0())) -> c_8() 7:W:+#(S(0()),y) -> c_9() 8:W:<#(x,0()) -> c_10() 9:W:<#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11() 10:W:<#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)) -->_1 <#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)):10 -->_1 <#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11():9 -->_1 <#(x,0()) -> c_10():8 11:W:bsort#(0(),xs) -> c_1() 12:W:bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) -->_1 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)):3 -->_1 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():2 13:W:bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) -->_1 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)):3 -->_1 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():2 14:W:len#(Nil()) -> c_7() The following weak DPs constitute a sub-graph of the DG that is closed under successors. The DPs are removed. 6: +#(x,S(0())) -> c_8() 7: +#(S(0()),y) -> c_9() 14: len#(Nil()) -> c_7() 11: bsort#(0(),xs) -> c_1() 10: <#(S(x),S(y)) -> c_12(<#(x,y)) 8: <#(x,0()) -> c_10() 9: <#(0(),S(y)) -> c_11() * Step 4: SimplifyRHS WORST_CASE(?,O(n^2)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)) - Weak DPs: bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bsort(0(),xs) -> xs bsort(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubblesort(xs) -> bsort(len(xs),xs) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) -->_2 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)):3 -->_2 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():2 -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)):1 2:S:bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() 3:S:bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)) -->_1 bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)):13 -->_1 bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)):12 4:S:bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) -->_2 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)):5 -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)):1 5:S:len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)) -->_2 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(+#(S(0()),len(xs)),len#(xs)):5 12:W:bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) -->_1 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)):3 -->_1 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():2 13:W:bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) -->_1 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)),<#(x',x)):3 -->_1 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():2 Due to missing edges in the depndency graph, the right-hand sides of following rules could be simplified: bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) * Step 5: UsableRules WORST_CASE(?,O(n^2)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) - Weak DPs: bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bsort(0(),xs) -> xs bsort(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) bubblesort(xs) -> bsort(len(xs),xs) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) * Step 6: DecomposeDG WORST_CASE(?,O(n^2)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) - Weak DPs: bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) and a lower component bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) Further, following extension rules are added to the lower component. bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs) bubblesort#(xs) -> bsort#(len(xs),xs) bubblesort#(xs) -> len#(xs) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> len#(xs) ** Step 6.a:1: SimplifyRHS WORST_CASE(?,O(n^1)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)) -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)):1 2:S:bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) -->_2 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)):3 -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)),bubble#(x,xs)):1 3:S:len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) -->_1 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)):3 Due to missing edges in the depndency graph, the right-hand sides of following rules could be simplified: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs))) ** Step 6.a:2: WeightGap WORST_CASE(?,O(n^1)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs))) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, [1] x' + [1] xs + [2] = c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs))) len#(Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [1] > [1] xs + [0] = c_6(len#(xs)) Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: bubblesort#(xs) = [5] xs + [0] >= [5] xs + [0] = c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) +(x,S(0())) = [1] x + [3] >= [1] x + [3] = S(x) +(S(0()),y) = [1] y + [3] >= [1] y + [3] = S(y) <(x,0()) = [0] >= [0] = False() <(0(),S(y)) = [0] >= [0] = True() <(S(x),S(y)) = [0] >= [0] = <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) = [1] >= [1] = Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [2] >= [1] xs + [2] = bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [2] >= [1] xs + [2] = Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [2] >= [1] xs + [2] = Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) = [3] xs + [3] >= [3] xs + [3] = +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) = [0] >= [0] = 0() Further, it can be verified that all rules not oriented are covered by the weightgap condition. ** Step 6.a:3: WeightGap WORST_CASE(?,O(n^1)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) - Weak DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs))) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, [1] xs + [4] = c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) = [1] x' + [1] xs + [0] >= [1] x' + [1] xs + [0] = c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs))) len#(Cons(x,xs)) = [4] >= [4] = c_6(len#(xs)) +(x,S(0())) = [1] x + [0] >= [1] x + [0] = S(x) +(S(0()),y) = [1] y + [0] >= [1] y + [0] = S(y) <(x,0()) = [0] >= [0] = False() <(0(),S(y)) = [0] >= [0] = True() <(S(x),S(y)) = [0] >= [0] = <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) = [0] >= [0] = Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [0] >= [1] xs + [0] = bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [0] >= [1] xs + [0] = Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [0] >= [1] xs + [0] = Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) = [0] >= [0] = +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) = [0] >= [0] = 0() Further, it can be verified that all rules not oriented are covered by the weightgap condition. ** Step 6.a:4: EmptyProcessor WORST_CASE(?,O(1)) + Considered Problem: - Weak DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> c_2(bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs))) bubblesort#(xs) -> c_5(bsort#(len(xs),xs),len#(xs)) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> c_6(len#(xs)) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) - Weak DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) -> bsort#(len(xs),xs) bubblesort#(xs) -> len#(xs) len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> len#(xs) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, c_3() 2:S:bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) -->_1 bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)):6 -->_1 bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)):5 3:W:bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs):4 -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)):3 4:W:bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs) -->_1 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))):2 -->_1 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():1 5:W:bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) -->_1 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))):2 -->_1 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():1 6:W:bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) -->_1 bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))):2 -->_1 bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3():1 7:W:bubblesort#(xs) -> bsort#(len(xs),xs) -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs):4 -->_1 bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)):3 8:W:bubblesort#(xs) -> len#(xs) -->_1 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> len#(xs):9 9:W:len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> len#(xs) -->_1 len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> len#(xs):9 The following weak DPs constitute a sub-graph of the DG that is closed under successors. The DPs are removed. 8: bubblesort#(xs) -> len#(xs) 9: len#(Cons(x,xs)) -> len#(xs) ** Step 6.b:2: WeightGap WORST_CASE(?,O(n^1)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) - Weak DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) -> bsort#(len(xs),xs) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, [0] = c_3() Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) = [1] x' + [1] xs + [4] >= [1] x' + [4] = bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) = [1] x' + [1] xs + [4] >= [2] = bubble#(x,xs) bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) = [2] >= [7] = c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [2] >= [2] = c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [2] >= [2] = c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) = [1] xs + [5] >= [1] xs + [4] = bsort#(len(xs),xs) +(x,S(0())) = [4] x + [0] >= [1] x + [0] = S(x) +(S(0()),y) = [1] y + [0] >= [1] y + [0] = S(y) <(x,0()) = [0] >= [0] = False() <(0(),S(y)) = [0] >= [0] = True() <(S(x),S(y)) = [0] >= [0] = <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) = [0] >= [0] = Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) = [0] >= [0] = bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [0] >= [0] = Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [0] >= [0] = Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) = [0] >= [0] = +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) = [0] >= [0] = 0() Further, it can be verified that all rules not oriented are covered by the weightgap condition. ** Step 6.b:3: NaturalMI WORST_CASE(?,O(n^1)) + Considered Problem: - Strict DPs: bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) - Weak DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) -> bsort#(len(xs),xs) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2, [2] xs + [12] = c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) = [2] xs + [8] >= [2] xs + [8] = bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) = [2] xs + [8] >= [2] xs + [6] = bubble#(x,xs) bubble#(x,Nil()) = [8] >= [4] = c_3() bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [2] xs + [12] >= [2] xs + [12] = c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [2] xs + [12] >= [2] xs + [6] = c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) = [4] xs + [4] >= [2] xs + [0] = bsort#(len(xs),xs) <(x,0()) = [1] >= [1] = False() <(0(),S(y)) = [1] >= [1] = True() <(S(x),S(y)) = [1] >= [1] = <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) = [5] >= [5] = Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [8] >= [1] xs + [8] = bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [8] >= [1] xs + [8] = Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) = [1] xs + [8] >= [1] xs + [8] = Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) ** Step 6.b:4: EmptyProcessor WORST_CASE(?,O(1)) + Considered Problem: - Weak DPs: bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bsort#(x',bubble(x,xs)) bsort#(S(x'),Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble#(x,xs) bubble#(x,Nil()) -> c_3() bubble#(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_4(bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs))) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_13(bubble#(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite]#(True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> c_14(bubble#(x,xs)) bubblesort#(xs) -> bsort#(len(xs),xs) - Weak TRS: +(x,S(0())) -> S(x) +(S(0()),y) -> S(y) <(x,0()) -> False() <(0(),S(y)) -> True() <(S(x),S(y)) -> <(x,y) bubble(x,Nil()) -> Cons(x,Nil()) bubble(x',Cons(x,xs)) -> bubble[Ite][False][Ite](<(x',x),x',Cons(x,xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](False(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x,bubble(x',xs)) bubble[Ite][False][Ite](True(),x',Cons(x,xs)) -> Cons(x',bubble(x,xs)) len(Cons(x,xs)) -> +(S(0()),len(xs)) len(Nil()) -> 0() - Signature: {+/2,