YES Problem: a(a(y,0()),0()) -> y c(c(y)) -> y c(a(c(c(y)),x)) -> a(c(c(c(a(x,0())))),y) Proof: Matrix Interpretation Processor: dim=1 interpretation: [c](x0) = 2x0 + 1, [a](x0, x1) = x0 + 4x1, [0] = 0 orientation: a(a(y,0()),0()) = y >= y = y c(c(y)) = 4y + 3 >= y = y c(a(c(c(y)),x)) = 8x + 8y + 7 >= 8x + 4y + 7 = a(c(c(c(a(x,0())))),y) problem: a(a(y,0()),0()) -> y c(a(c(c(y)),x)) -> a(c(c(c(a(x,0())))),y) Bounds Processor: bound: 3 enrichment: match automaton: final states: {2,1} transitions: 03() -> 148* a1(93,17) -> 26,18 a1(101,59) -> 26* a1(69,99) -> 27* a1(93,25) -> 27,19 a1(81,67) -> 17,25 a1(67,48) -> 90* a1(81,79) -> 17,25 a1(17,48) -> 90* a1(85,9) -> 34* a1(119,48) -> 144* a1(61,4) -> 33* a1(79,48) -> 90* a1(61,6) -> 25* a1(61,8) -> 33* a1(59,48) -> 66* a1(69,50) -> 43,19,7,27 a1(61,10) -> 25* a1(93,79) -> 26,18 a1(9,48) -> 66* a1(4,48) -> 82* a1(93,91) -> 19,27 a1(52,5) -> 26,18,42,6 a1(52,9) -> 26,18,42,6 a1(113,4) -> 99* a1(85,59) -> 34* a1(113,6) -> 91* a1(113,8) -> 99* a1(113,10) -> 91* a1(81,50) -> 43,19,7,27 a1(6,48) -> 98* a1(1,48) -> 49* a1(69,5) -> 43,27,7,16,19,24 a1(48,48) -> 110* a1(69,33) -> 27* a1(8,48) -> 82* a1(69,41) -> 35* a1(3,48) -> 58* a1(101,9) -> 26* a1(81,5) -> 43,7,16,19,24 a1(147,4) -> 121* a1(147,8) -> 121* a1(81,17) -> 25,17 a1(50,48) -> 78* a1(10,48) -> 98* a1(5,48) -> 78* a1(69,83) -> 35* c1(60) -> 61* c1(50) -> 51* c1(112) -> 113* c1(92) -> 93* c1(82) -> 83* c1(67) -> 68* c1(144) -> 145* c1(99) -> 100* c1(84) -> 85* c1(79) -> 80* c1(59) -> 60* c1(49) -> 50* c1(146) -> 147* c1(111) -> 112* c1(91) -> 92* c1(66) -> 67* c1(51) -> 52* c1(98) -> 99* c1(83) -> 84* c1(78) -> 79* c1(68) -> 69* c1(58) -> 59* c1(145) -> 146* c1(110) -> 111* c1(100) -> 101* c1(90) -> 91* c1(80) -> 81* 01() -> 48* a2(10,119) -> 120* a2(131,111) -> 100* a2(139,121) -> 93* a2(139,129) -> 101* a2(4,119) -> 128* a2(123,111) -> 92* a2(111,119) -> 136* a2(6,119) -> 120* a2(131,145) -> 122* a2(8,119) -> 128* c2(137) -> 138* c2(122) -> 123* c2(129) -> 130* c2(136) -> 137* c2(121) -> 122* c2(138) -> 139* c2(128) -> 129* c2(130) -> 131* c2(120) -> 121* f30() -> 1* 02() -> 119* a0(43,9) -> 34* a0(8,3) -> 40* a0(3,3) -> 8* a0(10,3) -> 32* a0(35,9) -> 26* a0(5,3) -> 16* a0(11,4) -> 33* a0(11,6) -> 25* a0(11,8) -> 33* a0(11,10) -> 25* a0(17,3) -> 24* a0(7,1) -> 2* a0(7,5) -> 42,18,6 a0(7,9) -> 42,26,18,6 a0(27,17) -> 26,18 a0(27,25) -> 27,19 a0(19,5) -> 43,27,19,7 a0(9,3) -> 16* a0(4,3) -> 40* a0(19,17) -> 25,17 a0(19,33) -> 27* a0(19,41) -> 35* a0(11,1) -> 5* a0(6,3) -> 32* a0(1,3) -> 4* a3(152,129) -> 123* a3(145,148) -> 149* c0(40) -> 41* c0(25) -> 26* c0(10) -> 11* c0(5) -> 6* c0(42) -> 43* c0(32) -> 33* c0(17) -> 18* c0(34) -> 35* c0(24) -> 25* c0(9) -> 10* c0(4) -> 5* c0(41) -> 42* c0(26) -> 27* c0(16) -> 17* c0(6) -> 7* c0(33) -> 34* c0(18) -> 19* c0(8) -> 9* c3(149) -> 150* c3(151) -> 152* c3(150) -> 151* 00() -> 3* 1 -> 128,82,40,4 2 -> 5* 3 -> 128,82,40 5 -> 41,25,17 7 -> 24,16 11 -> 24,16 problem: Qed