YES Problem: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Proof: DP Processor: DPs: minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> quot#(minus(x,y),s(y)) app#(add(n,x),y) -> app#(x,y) reverse#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) reverse#(add(n,x)) -> app#(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> shuffle#(reverse(x)) concat#(cons(u,v),y) -> concat#(v,y) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(w,z) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(u,v) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) TDG Processor: DPs: minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> quot#(minus(x,y),s(y)) app#(add(n,x),y) -> app#(x,y) reverse#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) reverse#(add(n,x)) -> app#(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> shuffle#(reverse(x)) concat#(cons(u,v),y) -> concat#(v,y) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(w,z) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(u,v) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) graph: less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(u,v) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(w,z) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(w,z) -> concat#(cons(u,v),y) -> concat#(v,y) less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> concat#(u,v) -> concat#(cons(u,v),y) -> concat#(v,y) concat#(cons(u,v),y) -> concat#(v,y) -> concat#(cons(u,v),y) -> concat#(v,y) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> shuffle#(reverse(x)) -> shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> shuffle#(reverse(x)) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> shuffle#(reverse(x)) -> shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) -> reverse#(add(n,x)) -> app#(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) -> reverse#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) reverse#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) -> reverse#(add(n,x)) -> app#(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) reverse#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) -> reverse#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) reverse#(add(n,x)) -> app#(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) -> app#(add(n,x),y) -> app#(x,y) app#(add(n,x),y) -> app#(x,y) -> app#(add(n,x),y) -> app#(x,y) quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> quot#(minus(x,y),s(y)) -> quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> quot#(minus(x,y),s(y)) quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> quot#(minus(x,y),s(y)) -> quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) -> minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) -> minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) SCC Processor: #sccs: 7 #rules: 7 #arcs: 18/144 DPs: quot#(s(x),s(y)) -> quot#(minus(x,y),s(y)) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Arctic Interpretation Processor: dimension: 1 interpretation: [quot#](x0, x1) = 1x0, [true] = 3, [false] = 0, [less_leaves](x0, x1) = 3x0 + 3x1, [cons](x0, x1) = 4x0 + x1 + 0, [concat](x0, x1) = 1x0 + x1, [leaf] = 0, [shuffle](x0) = 3, [reverse](x0) = 6x0 + 2, [add](x0, x1) = 0, [app](x0, x1) = 2x1 + 0, [nil] = 0, [quot](x0, x1) = x0, [s](x0) = 1x0, [minus](x0, x1) = x0, [0] = 1 orientation: quot#(s(x),s(y)) = 2x >= 1x = quot#(minus(x,y),s(y)) minus(x,0()) = x >= x = x minus(s(x),s(y)) = 1x >= x = minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) = 1 >= 1 = 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) = 1x >= 1x = s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) = 2y + 0 >= y = y app(add(n,x),y) = 2y + 0 >= 0 = add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) = 6 >= 0 = nil() reverse(add(n,x)) = 6 >= 2 = app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) = 3 >= 0 = nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) = 3 >= 0 = add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) = y + 1 >= y = y concat(cons(u,v),y) = 5u + 1v + y + 1 >= 4u + 1v + y + 0 = cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) = 3x + 3 >= 0 = false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) = 7w + 3z + 3 >= 3 = true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) = 7u + 3v + 7w + 3z + 3 >= 4u + 3v + 4w + 3z = less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) problem: DPs: TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Qed DPs: minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(minus#) = 1 problem: DPs: TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Qed DPs: shuffle#(add(n,x)) -> shuffle#(reverse(x)) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Matrix Interpretation Processor: dim=1 interpretation: [shuffle#](x0) = 6x0, [true] = 0, [false] = 0, [less_leaves](x0, x1) = 4x0 + 3, [cons](x0, x1) = 4x0 + x1, [concat](x0, x1) = 2x0 + x1, [leaf] = 3, [shuffle](x0) = 4x0 + 5, [reverse](x0) = x0 + 3, [add](x0, x1) = x1 + 4, [app](x0, x1) = x0 + x1, [nil] = 0, [quot](x0, x1) = 2, [s](x0) = x0, [minus](x0, x1) = 2x0 + 2, [0] = 2 orientation: shuffle#(add(n,x)) = 6x + 24 >= 6x + 18 = shuffle#(reverse(x)) minus(x,0()) = 2x + 2 >= x = x minus(s(x),s(y)) = 2x + 2 >= 2x + 2 = minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) = 2 >= 2 = 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) = 2 >= 2 = s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) = y >= y = y app(add(n,x),y) = x + y + 4 >= x + y + 4 = add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) = 3 >= 0 = nil() reverse(add(n,x)) = x + 7 >= x + 7 = app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) = 5 >= 0 = nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) = 4x + 21 >= 4x + 21 = add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) = y + 6 >= y = y concat(cons(u,v),y) = 8u + 2v + y >= 4u + 2v + y = cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) = 4x + 3 >= 0 = false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) = 15 >= 0 = true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) = 16u + 4v + 3 >= 8u + 4v + 3 = less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) problem: DPs: TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Qed DPs: reverse#(add(n,x)) -> reverse#(x) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(reverse#) = 0 problem: DPs: TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Qed DPs: app#(add(n,x),y) -> app#(x,y) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(app#) = 0 problem: DPs: TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Qed DPs: less_leaves#(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves#(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) KBO Processor: argument filtering: pi(0) = [] pi(minus) = 0 pi(s) = 0 pi(quot) = [1] pi(nil) = [] pi(app) = 1 pi(add) = 1 pi(reverse) = [] pi(shuffle) = [] pi(leaf) = [] pi(concat) = [0,1] pi(cons) = [0,1] pi(less_leaves) = 1 pi(false) = [] pi(true) = [] pi(less_leaves#) = 1 weight function: w0 = 1 w(less_leaves#) = w(true) = w(false) = w(less_leaves) = w(cons) = w( leaf) = w(shuffle) = w(reverse) = w(app) = w(nil) = w(quot) = w( s) = w(minus) = w(0) = 1 w(concat) = w(add) = 0 precedence: app ~ s > true ~ concat ~ leaf ~ shuffle ~ quot ~ minus ~ 0 > reverse > less_leaves# ~ false ~ less_leaves ~ cons ~ add ~ nil problem: DPs: TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Qed DPs: concat#(cons(u,v),y) -> concat#(v,y) TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Subterm Criterion Processor: simple projection: pi(concat#) = 0 problem: DPs: TRS: minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) quot(0(),s(y)) -> 0() quot(s(x),s(y)) -> s(quot(minus(x,y),s(y))) app(nil(),y) -> y app(add(n,x),y) -> add(n,app(x,y)) reverse(nil()) -> nil() reverse(add(n,x)) -> app(reverse(x),add(n,nil())) shuffle(nil()) -> nil() shuffle(add(n,x)) -> add(n,shuffle(reverse(x))) concat(leaf(),y) -> y concat(cons(u,v),y) -> cons(u,concat(v,y)) less_leaves(x,leaf()) -> false() less_leaves(leaf(),cons(w,z)) -> true() less_leaves(cons(u,v),cons(w,z)) -> less_leaves(concat(u,v),concat(w,z)) Qed