MAYBE Problem: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) Proof: DP Processor: DPs: minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> p#(ack(0(),x)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) TRS: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) Usable Rule Processor: DPs: minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> p#(ack(0(),x)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) TRS: f18(x,y) -> x f18(x,y) -> y plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) TDG Processor: DPs: minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> p#(ack(0(),x)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) TRS: f18(x,y) -> x f18(x,y) -> y plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) graph: ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) -> ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) -> ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) -> ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) -> ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) -> ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) -> ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) -> ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) -> ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) -> ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> p#(ack(0(),x)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) -> minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) -> minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) -> minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> p#(ack(0(),x)) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) -> quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) -> minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) -> minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) -> minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) -> plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) -> minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) -> minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) -> minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) Restore Modifier: DPs: minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> plus#(y,z) minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) div#(x,y) -> quot#(x,y,0()) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> ack#(0(),x) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> p#(ack(0(),x)) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> minus#(p(ack(0(),x)),y) quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) ack#(0(),x) -> plus#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) TRS: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) SCC Processor: #sccs: 4 #rules: 8 #arcs: 41/196 DPs: quot#(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot#(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) TRS: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) Open DPs: minus#(minus(x,y),z) -> minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) TRS: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) Matrix Interpretation Processor: dimension: 1 interpretation: [minus#](x0, x1) = x0 + 1, [ack](x0, x1) = x1, [quot](x0, x1, x2) = x1 + x2 + 1, [div](x0, x1) = x1 + 1, [p](x0) = x0, [true] = 0, [false] = 0, [zero](x0) = 0, [s](x0) = x0, [0] = 0, [plus](x0, x1) = x0 + x1, [minus](x0, x1) = x0 + x1 + 1 orientation: minus#(minus(x,y),z) = x + y + 2 >= x + 1 = minus#(x,plus(y,z)) minus#(s(x),s(y)) = x + 1 >= x + 1 = minus#(x,y) minus(minus(x,y),z) = x + y + z + 2 >= x + y + z + 1 = minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) = y + 1 >= 0 = 0() minus(x,0()) = x + 1 >= x = x minus(s(x),s(y)) = x + y + 1 >= x + y + 1 = minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) = y >= y = y plus(s(x),y) = x + y >= x + y = plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) = x + y >= x + y = s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) = 0 >= 0 = false() zero(0()) = 0 >= 0 = true() p(s(x)) = x >= x = x p(0()) = 0 >= 0 = 0() div(x,y) = y + 1 >= y + 1 = quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) = y + z + 1 >= y + z + 1 = quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) = y + z + 1 >= z = z ack(0(),x) = x >= x = s(x) ack(0(),x) = x >= x = plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) = 0 >= 0 = ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) = y >= y = ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) problem: DPs: minus#(s(x),s(y)) -> minus#(x,y) TRS: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) Open DPs: ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(s(x),y) ack#(s(x),0()) -> ack#(x,s(0())) ack#(s(x),s(y)) -> ack#(x,ack(s(x),y)) TRS: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) Open DPs: plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(x,s(y)) plus#(s(x),y) -> plus#(y,x) TRS: minus(minus(x,y),z) -> minus(x,plus(y,z)) minus(0(),y) -> 0() minus(x,0()) -> x minus(s(x),s(y)) -> minus(x,y) plus(0(),y) -> y plus(s(x),y) -> plus(x,s(y)) plus(s(x),y) -> s(plus(y,x)) zero(s(x)) -> false() zero(0()) -> true() p(s(x)) -> x p(0()) -> 0() div(x,y) -> quot(x,y,0()) quot(s(x),s(y),z) -> quot(minus(p(ack(0(),x)),y),s(y),s(z)) quot(0(),s(y),z) -> z ack(0(),x) -> s(x) ack(0(),x) -> plus(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),0()) -> ack(x,s(0())) ack(s(x),s(y)) -> ack(x,ack(s(x),y)) Open