YES(?,O(n^2)) Problem: s(a()) -> a() s(s(x)) -> x s(f(x,y)) -> f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) -> g(s(x),s(y)) f(x,a()) -> x f(a(),y) -> y f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) -> g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) g(a(),a()) -> a() Proof: RT Transformation Processor: strict: s(a()) -> a() s(s(x)) -> x s(f(x,y)) -> f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) -> g(s(x),s(y)) f(x,a()) -> x f(a(),y) -> y f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) -> g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) g(a(),a()) -> a() weak: Matrix Interpretation Processor: dimension: 1 interpretation: [g](x0, x1) = x0 + x1 + 1, [f](x0, x1) = x0 + x1 + 1, [s](x0) = x0, [a] = 0 orientation: s(a()) = 0 >= 0 = a() s(s(x)) = x >= x = x s(f(x,y)) = x + y + 1 >= x + y + 1 = f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) = x + y + 1 >= x + y + 1 = g(s(x),s(y)) f(x,a()) = x + 1 >= x = x f(a(),y) = y + 1 >= y = y f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) = u + v + x + y + 3 >= u + v + x + y + 3 = g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) g(a(),a()) = 1 >= 0 = a() problem: strict: s(a()) -> a() s(s(x)) -> x s(f(x,y)) -> f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) -> g(s(x),s(y)) f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) -> g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) weak: f(x,a()) -> x f(a(),y) -> y g(a(),a()) -> a() Matrix Interpretation Processor: dimension: 1 interpretation: [g](x0, x1) = x0 + x1, [f](x0, x1) = x0 + x1, [s](x0) = x0 + 2, [a] = 0 orientation: s(a()) = 2 >= 0 = a() s(s(x)) = x + 4 >= x = x s(f(x,y)) = x + y + 2 >= x + y + 4 = f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) = x + y + 2 >= x + y + 4 = g(s(x),s(y)) f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) = u + v + x + y >= u + v + x + y = g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) f(x,a()) = x >= x = x f(a(),y) = y >= y = y g(a(),a()) = 0 >= 0 = a() problem: strict: s(f(x,y)) -> f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) -> g(s(x),s(y)) f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) -> g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) weak: s(a()) -> a() s(s(x)) -> x f(x,a()) -> x f(a(),y) -> y g(a(),a()) -> a() Matrix Interpretation Processor: dimension: 1 interpretation: [g](x0, x1) = x0 + x1 + 1, [f](x0, x1) = x0 + x1, [s](x0) = x0, [a] = 6 orientation: s(f(x,y)) = x + y >= x + y = f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) = x + y + 1 >= x + y + 1 = g(s(x),s(y)) f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) = u + v + x + y + 2 >= u + v + x + y + 1 = g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) s(a()) = 6 >= 6 = a() s(s(x)) = x >= x = x f(x,a()) = x + 6 >= x = x f(a(),y) = y + 6 >= y = y g(a(),a()) = 13 >= 6 = a() problem: strict: s(f(x,y)) -> f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) -> g(s(x),s(y)) weak: f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) -> g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) s(a()) -> a() s(s(x)) -> x f(x,a()) -> x f(a(),y) -> y g(a(),a()) -> a() Matrix Interpretation Processor: dimension: 2 interpretation: [1 1] [7] [g](x0, x1) = [0 1]x0 + x1 + [8], [3] [f](x0, x1) = x0 + x1 + [4], [1 2] [8] [s](x0) = [0 1]x0 + [0], [1] [a] = [0] orientation: [1 2] [1 2] [19] [1 2] [1 2] [19] s(f(x,y)) = [0 1]x + [0 1]y + [4 ] >= [0 1]x + [0 1]y + [4 ] = f(s(y),s(x)) [1 3] [1 2] [31] [1 3] [1 2] [23] s(g(x,y)) = [0 1]x + [0 1]y + [8 ] >= [0 1]x + [0 1]y + [8 ] = g(s(x),s(y)) [1 1] [1 1] [17] [1 1] [1 1] [17] f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) = [0 1]u + v + [0 1]x + y + [20] >= [0 1]u + v + [0 1]x + y + [16] = g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) [9] [1] s(a()) = [0] >= [0] = a() [1 4] [16] s(s(x)) = [0 1]x + [0 ] >= x = x [4] f(x,a()) = x + [4] >= x = x [4] f(a(),y) = y + [4] >= y = y [9] [1] g(a(),a()) = [8] >= [0] = a() problem: strict: s(f(x,y)) -> f(s(y),s(x)) weak: s(g(x,y)) -> g(s(x),s(y)) f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) -> g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) s(a()) -> a() s(s(x)) -> x f(x,a()) -> x f(a(),y) -> y g(a(),a()) -> a() Matrix Interpretation Processor: dimension: 2 interpretation: [1 9] [1 8] [0] [g](x0, x1) = [0 1]x0 + [0 1]x1 + [5], [1 2] [1 2] [1] [f](x0, x1) = [0 1]x0 + [0 1]x1 + [1], [1 2] [1] [s](x0) = [0 1]x0 + [0], [1] [a] = [0] orientation: [1 4] [1 4] [4] [1 4] [1 4] [3] s(f(x,y)) = [0 1]x + [0 1]y + [1] >= [0 1]x + [0 1]y + [1] = f(s(y),s(x)) [1 11] [1 10] [11] [1 11] [1 10] [2] s(g(x,y)) = [0 1 ]x + [0 1 ]y + [5 ] >= [0 1 ]x + [0 1 ]y + [5] = g(s(x),s(y)) [1 11] [1 10] [1 11] [1 10] [21] [1 11] [1 10] [1 11] [1 10] [19] f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) = [0 1 ]u + [0 1 ]v + [0 1 ]x + [0 1 ]y + [11] >= [0 1 ]u + [0 1 ]v + [0 1 ]x + [0 1 ]y + [7 ] = g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) [2] [1] s(a()) = [0] >= [0] = a() [1 4] [2] s(s(x)) = [0 1]x + [0] >= x = x [1 2] [2] f(x,a()) = [0 1]x + [1] >= x = x [1 2] [2] f(a(),y) = [0 1]y + [1] >= y = y [2] [1] g(a(),a()) = [5] >= [0] = a() problem: strict: weak: s(f(x,y)) -> f(s(y),s(x)) s(g(x,y)) -> g(s(x),s(y)) f(g(x,y),g(u,v)) -> g(f(x,u),f(y,v)) s(a()) -> a() s(s(x)) -> x f(x,a()) -> x f(a(),y) -> y g(a(),a()) -> a() Qed