YES Time: 0.003174 TRS: { +(+(x, y), z) -> +(x, +(y, z)), +(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +(b(), +(a(), z)), +(a(), b()) -> +(b(), a()), f(+(x, y), z) -> +(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f(b(), y) -> b(), f(a(), y) -> a()} DP: DP: { +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(b(), +(a(), z)), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z), +#(a(), b()) -> +#(b(), a()), f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)} TRS: { +(+(x, y), z) -> +(x, +(y, z)), +(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +(b(), +(a(), z)), +(a(), b()) -> +(b(), a()), f(+(x, y), z) -> +(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f(b(), y) -> b(), f(a(), y) -> a()} EDG: {(+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(a(), b()) -> +#(b(), a())) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z)) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(b(), +(a(), z))) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z))) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z)), +#(a(), b()) -> +#(b(), a())) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z)), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z)) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z)), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(b(), +(a(), z))) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z)), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z)), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z))) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z), +#(a(), b()) -> +#(b(), a())) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z)) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(b(), +(a(), z))) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)) (+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z))) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z)) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z))) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(f(x, z), f(y, z))) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z)) (f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)) (+#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(b(), +(a(), z))) (+#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z), +#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z)) (+#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z), +#(a(), b()) -> +#(b(), a()))} SCCS (3): Scc: {f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)} Scc: {+#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z)} Scc: {+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)} SCC (2): Strict: {f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(x, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)} Weak: { +(+(x, y), z) -> +(x, +(y, z)), +(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +(b(), +(a(), z)), +(a(), b()) -> +(b(), a()), f(+(x, y), z) -> +(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f(b(), y) -> b(), f(a(), y) -> a()} SPSC: Simple Projection: pi(f#) = 0 Strict: {f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)} EDG: {(f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z), f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z))} SCCS (1): Scc: {f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)} SCC (1): Strict: {f#(+(x, y), z) -> f#(y, z)} Weak: { +(+(x, y), z) -> +(x, +(y, z)), +(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +(b(), +(a(), z)), +(a(), b()) -> +(b(), a()), f(+(x, y), z) -> +(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f(b(), y) -> b(), f(a(), y) -> a()} SPSC: Simple Projection: pi(f#) = 0 Strict: {} Qed SCC (1): Strict: {+#(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +#(a(), z)} Weak: { +(+(x, y), z) -> +(x, +(y, z)), +(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +(b(), +(a(), z)), +(a(), b()) -> +(b(), a()), f(+(x, y), z) -> +(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f(b(), y) -> b(), f(a(), y) -> a()} SPSC: Simple Projection: pi(+#) = 1 Strict: {} Qed SCC (2): Strict: {+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(x, +(y, z)), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)} Weak: { +(+(x, y), z) -> +(x, +(y, z)), +(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +(b(), +(a(), z)), +(a(), b()) -> +(b(), a()), f(+(x, y), z) -> +(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f(b(), y) -> b(), f(a(), y) -> a()} SPSC: Simple Projection: pi(+#) = 0 Strict: {+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)} EDG: {(+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z), +#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z))} SCCS (1): Scc: {+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)} SCC (1): Strict: {+#(+(x, y), z) -> +#(y, z)} Weak: { +(+(x, y), z) -> +(x, +(y, z)), +(a(), +(b(), z)) -> +(b(), +(a(), z)), +(a(), b()) -> +(b(), a()), f(+(x, y), z) -> +(f(x, z), f(y, z)), f(b(), y) -> b(), f(a(), y) -> a()} SPSC: Simple Projection: pi(+#) = 0 Strict: {} Qed