YES Time: 0.363 Problem: Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) Proof: DP Processor: Equations#: p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) p{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> p{AC,#}(x4,x3) m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) m{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> m{AC,#}(x4,x3) p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) p{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> p{AC,#}(x3,x4) m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) m{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> m{AC,#}(x3,x4) DPs: p{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> p{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),y) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> m{AC,#}(x,z) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) p{AC,#}(x6,pAC(x,zero())) -> p{AC,#}(x6,x) m{AC,#}(x7,mAC(x,zero())) -> m{AC,#}(x7,zero()) p{AC,#}(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(x,y) p{AC,#}(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(x8,s(pAC(x,y))) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),y) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> m{AC,#}(x9,pAC(mAC(x,y),y)) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x,z) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x10,pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z))) Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) S: p{AC,#}(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> p{AC,#}(x11,x12) p{AC,#}(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> p{AC,#}(x12,x13) m{AC,#}(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> m{AC,#}(x11,x12) m{AC,#}(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> m{AC,#}(x12,x13) AC-EDG Processor: Equations#: p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) p{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> p{AC,#}(x4,x3) m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) m{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> m{AC,#}(x4,x3) p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) p{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> p{AC,#}(x3,x4) m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) m{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> m{AC,#}(x3,x4) DPs: p{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> p{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),y) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> m{AC,#}(x,z) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) p{AC,#}(x6,pAC(x,zero())) -> p{AC,#}(x6,x) m{AC,#}(x7,mAC(x,zero())) -> m{AC,#}(x7,zero()) p{AC,#}(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(x,y) p{AC,#}(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(x8,s(pAC(x,y))) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),y) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> m{AC,#}(x9,pAC(mAC(x,y),y)) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x,z) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> p{AC,#}(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x10,pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z))) Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) S: p{AC,#}(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> p{AC,#}(x11,x12) p{AC,#}(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> p{AC,#}(x12,x13) m{AC,#}(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> m{AC,#}(x11,x12) m{AC,#}(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> m{AC,#}(x12,x13) SCC Processor: #sccs: 2 #rules: 13 #arcs: 149/289 Equations#: p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) p{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> p{AC,#}(x4,x3) m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) m{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> m{AC,#}(x4,x3) p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) p{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> p{AC,#}(x3,x4) m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) m{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> m{AC,#}(x3,x4) DPs: m{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x10,pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z))) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> m{AC,#}(x,z) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> m{AC,#}(x9,pAC(mAC(x,y),y)) m{AC,#}(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x7,mAC(x,zero())) -> m{AC,#}(x7,zero()) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> m{AC,#}(x,y) m{AC,#}(x,pAC(y,z)) -> m{AC,#}(x,z) Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) S: p{AC,#}(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> p{AC,#}(x11,x12) p{AC,#}(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> p{AC,#}(x12,x13) m{AC,#}(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> m{AC,#}(x11,x12) m{AC,#}(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> m{AC,#}(x12,x13) AC-DP unlabeling: Equations#: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) DPs: mAC(s(x),y) -> mAC(x,y) mAC(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> mAC(x10,pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z))) mAC(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> mAC(x,y) mAC(x10,mAC(x,pAC(y,z))) -> mAC(x,z) mAC(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> mAC(x9,pAC(mAC(x,y),y)) mAC(x9,mAC(s(x),y)) -> mAC(x,y) mAC(x7,mAC(x,zero())) -> mAC(x7,zero()) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> mAC(x,y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> mAC(x,z) Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) S: pAC(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> pAC(x11,x12) pAC(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> pAC(x12,x13) mAC(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> mAC(x11,x12) mAC(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> mAC(x12,x13) AC-RPO Processor: argument filtering: pi(pAC) = [0,1] pi(mAC) = [0,1] pi(zero) = [] pi(s) = [] precedence: s > mAC > zero > pAC status: problem: Equations#: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) DPs: Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) S: pAC(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> pAC(x11,x12) pAC(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> pAC(x12,x13) mAC(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> mAC(x11,x12) mAC(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> mAC(x12,x13) Qed Equations#: p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) p{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> p{AC,#}(x4,x3) m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) m{AC,#}(x3,x4) -> m{AC,#}(x4,x3) p{AC,#}(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> p{AC,#}(pAC(x3,x4),x5) p{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> p{AC,#}(x3,x4) m{AC,#}(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> m{AC,#}(mAC(x3,x4),x5) m{AC,#}(x4,x3) -> m{AC,#}(x3,x4) DPs: p{AC,#}(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(x8,s(pAC(x,y))) p{AC,#}(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> p{AC,#}(x,y) p{AC,#}(x6,pAC(x,zero())) -> p{AC,#}(x6,x) p{AC,#}(s(x),y) -> p{AC,#}(x,y) Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) S: p{AC,#}(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> p{AC,#}(x11,x12) p{AC,#}(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> p{AC,#}(x12,x13) m{AC,#}(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> m{AC,#}(x11,x12) m{AC,#}(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> m{AC,#}(x12,x13) AC-DP unlabeling: Equations#: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) DPs: pAC(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> pAC(x8,s(pAC(x,y))) pAC(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> pAC(x,y) pAC(x6,pAC(x,zero())) -> pAC(x6,x) pAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(x,y) Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(x,zero()) -> x mAC(x,zero()) -> zero() pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) mAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),y) mAC(x,pAC(y,z)) -> pAC(mAC(x,y),mAC(x,z)) S: pAC(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> pAC(x11,x12) pAC(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> pAC(x12,x13) mAC(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> mAC(x11,x12) mAC(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> mAC(x12,x13) Usable Rule Processor: Equations#: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) DPs: pAC(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> pAC(x8,s(pAC(x,y))) pAC(x8,pAC(s(x),y)) -> pAC(x,y) pAC(x6,pAC(x,zero())) -> pAC(x6,x) pAC(s(x),y) -> pAC(x,y) Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) pAC(x,zero()) -> x S: pAC(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> pAC(x11,x12) pAC(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> pAC(x12,x13) mAC(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> mAC(x11,x12) mAC(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> mAC(x12,x13) AC-RPO Processor: argument filtering: pi(pAC) = [0,1] pi(mAC) = [0,1] pi(zero) = [] pi(s) = [] precedence: zero > mAC > pAC > s status: problem: Equations#: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) DPs: Equations: pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) -> pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) pAC(x3,x4) -> pAC(x4,x3) mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) -> mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) mAC(x3,x4) -> mAC(x4,x3) pAC(x3,pAC(x4,x5)) -> pAC(pAC(x3,x4),x5) pAC(x4,x3) -> pAC(x3,x4) mAC(x3,mAC(x4,x5)) -> mAC(mAC(x3,x4),x5) mAC(x4,x3) -> mAC(x3,x4) TRS: pAC(s(x),y) -> s(pAC(x,y)) pAC(x,zero()) -> x S: pAC(pAC(x11,x12),x13) -> pAC(x11,x12) pAC(x11,pAC(x12,x13)) -> pAC(x12,x13) mAC(mAC(x11,x12),x13) -> mAC(x11,x12) mAC(x11,mAC(x12,x13)) -> mAC(x12,x13) Qed